The Department of Internal Affairs

The Department of Internal Affairs

Te Tari Taiwhenua

Building a safe, prosperous and respected nation

 

Resource material › Corporate Publications › Annual Report 2013-14Pūrongo ā Tau

Part B: Service performance

This section summarises our performance against the performance measures set out in the Information Supporting the Estimates of Appropriations.

Statement of Responsibility

As Secretary for Internal Affairs I am responsible, under the Public Finance Act 1989, for the preparation of the Financial Statements, the Statement of Service Performance, the Forecast Financial Statements, and the judgements made in the process of producing those statements.

The Department has a system of internal control and this has provided reasonable assurance as to the integrity and reliability of financial reporting. In my opinion the Financial Statements and Statement of Service Performance and Forecast Financial Statements fairly reflect the financial position and operations of the Department of Internal Affairs for the year ended 30 June 2014.

Colin MacDonald's signature

Colin MacDonald
Chief Executive
September 2014

Matthew Needham's signature

Matthew Needham
Chief Financial Officer
September 2014

Back to top

Independent Auditor’s Report

To the readers of The Department of Internal Affairs’ financial statements, non‑financial performance information and schedules of non‑departmental activities for the year ended 30  June 2014

The Auditor‑General is the auditor of the Department of Internal Affairs (the Department). The Auditor‑General has appointed me, Clare Helm, using the staff and resources of Audit New Zealand, to carry out the audit of the financial statements, the non‑financial performance information and the schedules of non‑departmental activities of the Department on her behalf.

We have audited:

Opinion

In our opinion:

  • the financial statements of the Department in Part C: 2013/14 Financial Statements – Departmental:
    • comply with generally accepted accounting practice in New Zealand; and
    • fairly reflect the Department’s:
      • financial position as at 30  June 2014;
      • financial performance and cash flows for the year ended on that date;
      • expenses and capital expenditure incurred against each appropriation administered by the Department and each class of outputs included in each output expense appropriation for the year ended 30  June 2014; and
      • unappropriated expenses and capital expenditure for the year ended 30  June 2014.
  • the non-financial performance information of the Department in Part B: Service Performance, and sections of Part A: Contribution to Outcomes and Objectives - our outcomes and objectives, contributing to outcomes and objectives, outcome indicators and objectives indicators:
    • complies with generally accepted accounting practice in New Zealand; and
    • fairly reflects the Department’s service performance, outcomes and objectives for the year ended 30 June 2014, including for each class of outputs:
      • its service performance compared with the forecasts in the statement of forecast service performance at the start of the financial year; and
      • its actual revenue and output expenses compared with the forecasts in the statement of forecast service performance at the start of the financial year.
  • the schedules of non‑departmental activities of the Department in Part D: 2013/14 Financial Statements – Non-Departmental:
    • comply with generally accepted accounting practice in New Zealand; and
    • fairly reflect:
      • the assets, liabilities, contingencies, commitments and trust monies as at 30  June 2014 managed by the Department on behalf of the Crown; and
      • the revenues, expenses, expenditure and capital expenditure against appropriations and unappropriated expenditure and capital expenditure for the year ended on that date managed by the Department on behalf of the Crown.

Our audit was completed on 30 September 2014. This is the date at which our opinion is expressed.

The basis of our opinion is explained below. In addition, we outline the responsibilities of the Chief Executive and our responsibilities, and we explain our independence.

Basis of opinion

We carried out our audit in accordance with the Auditor-General’s Auditing Standards, which incorporate the International Standards on Auditing (New Zealand). Those standards require that we comply with ethical requirements and plan and carry out our audit to obtain reasonable assurance about whether the financial statements, the non-financial performance information and the schedules of non-departmental activities are free from material misstatement.

Material misstatements are differences or omissions of amounts and disclosures that, in our judgement, are likely to influence readers’ overall understanding of the financial statements, the non-financial performance information and the schedules of non-departmental activities. If we had found material misstatements that were not corrected, we would have referred to them in our opinion.

An audit involves carrying out procedures to obtain audit evidence about the amounts and disclosures in the financial statements financial statements, the non-financial performance information and the schedules of non-departmental activities. The procedures selected depend on our judgement, including our assessment of risks of material misstatement of the financial statements, the non-financial performance information and the schedules of non-departmental activities, whether due to fraud or error. In making those risk assessments, we consider internal control relevant to the Department’s preparation of the financial statements, the non-financial performance information and the schedules of non-departmental activities that fairly reflect the matters to which they relate. We consider internal control in order to design audit procedures that are appropriate in the circumstances but not for the purpose of expressing an opinion on the effectiveness of the Department’s internal control.

An audit also involves evaluating:

  • the appropriateness of accounting policies used and whether they have been consistently applied;
  • the reasonableness of the significant accounting estimates and judgements made by the Chief Executive;
  • the appropriateness of the reported non-financial performance information within the Department’s framework for reporting performance;
  • the adequacy of all disclosures in the financial statements, the non-financial performance information and the schedules of non-departmental activities; and
  • the overall presentation of the financial statements, the non-financial performance information and the schedules of non-departmental activities.

We did not examine every transaction, nor do we guarantee complete accuracy of the financial statements, the non-financial performance information and the schedules of non-departmental activities. Also we did not evaluate the security and controls over the electronic publication of the financial statements, the non-financial performance information and the schedules of non-departmental activities

We have obtained all the information and explanations we have required and we believe we have obtained sufficient and appropriate audit evidence to provide a basis for our audit opinion.

Responsibilities of the Chief Executive

The Chief Executive is responsible for preparing:

  • financial statements and non‑financial performance information that:
    • comply with generally accepted accounting practice in New Zealand;
    • fairly reflect the Department’s financial position, financial performance, cash flows, expenses and capital expenditure incurred against each appropriation and its unappropriated expenses and capital expenditure; and
    • fairly reflect its service performance and outcomes; and
  • schedules of non‑departmental activities, in accordance with the Treasury Instructions that fairly reflect those activities managed by the Department on behalf of the Crown.

The Chief Executive is also responsible for such internal control as is determined is necessary to enable the preparation of financial statements, and non‑financial performance information and schedules of non‑departmental activities that are free from material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error.

The Chief Executive is also responsible for the publication of the financial statements, non-financial performance information and schedules of non-departmental activities, whether in printed or electronic form.

The Chief Executive’s responsibilities arise from the Public Finance Act 1989.

Responsibilities of the Auditor

We are responsible for expressing an independent opinion on the financial statements, the non‑financial performance information and the schedules of non‑departmental activities and reporting that opinion to you based on our audit. Our responsibility arises from section 15 of the Public Audit Act 2001 and the Public Finance Act 1989.

Independence

When carrying out the audit, we followed the independence requirements of the Auditor‑General, which incorporate the independence requirements of the External Reporting Board.

In addition to the audit we have carried out an assignment witnessing the Passport Key Generation Ceremonies, which is compatible with those independence requirements. Other than the audit and this assignment, we have no relationship with or interests in the Department.

Clare Helm's signature

Clare Helm
Audit New Zealand

On behalf of the Auditor‑General
Wellington, New Zealand

Back to top

Introduction

This section summarises our performance against the measures set out in the Information Supporting the Estimates of Appropriations for each of the portfolios in Vote Internal Affairs.

The links between the Department’s outcomes and objectives, and Output Appropriations are provided in Appendix II.

We have assessed whether we met the standards associated with each output, and have provided an explanation where there is a significant difference between the standard and what we achieved. We have also included comparable information from 2012/13 where possible.

Note on definitions used for output performance measures

The following section includes measures of performance and measures of activity:

  • Performance information relates to output performance dimensions such as quality and timeliness that are within the Department’s control.
  • Activity information relates to output volume measures that are demand driven and therefore outside the Department’s control.

Back to top

Portfolio Index

The table below provides an index of performance measures within the seven portfolios supported by the Department of Internal Affairs.

Portfolio Index
Portfolio Output Appropriation
Internal Affairs Civic Information Services MCOA
Community Information and Advisory Services MCOA
Contestable Services RDA
Information and Technology Services MCOA
Ministerial Support Services MCOA – Crown Entity Monitoring
Ministerial Support Services MCOA – Internal Affairs
Policy Advice MCOA – Internal Affairs
Regulatory Services MCOA
Support for Statutory and Other Bodies MCOA
Ministerial Services Ministerial Support Services MCOA – Ministerial Services
Services Supporting the Executive MCOA
Support for Statutory and Other Bodies MCOA
Local Government Local Government Services
Ministerial Support Services MCOA – Local Government
Policy Advice MCOA – Local Government
Pitt Island Wharf Reconstruction
Ethnic Affairs Community Information and Advisory Services MCOA
Ministerial Support Services MCOA – Ethnic Affairs
Policy Advice MCOA – Ethnic Affairs
Racing Ministerial Support Services MCOA – Racing
Policy Advice MCOA – Racing
Community and Voluntary Sector Administration of Grants
Community Information and Advisory Services MCOA
Ministerial Support Services MCOA – Community and Voluntary Sector
Policy Advice MCOA – Community and Voluntary Sector
Regulatory Services MCOA
Community Funding Schemes MCA
Civil Defence and Emergency Management Community Information and Advisory Services MCOA
Emergency Management Services MCOA
Ministerial Support Services MCOA – Civil Defence
Policy Advice MCOA – Civil Defence

Back to top

Vote Internal Affairs

Appropriation: Administration of Grants

Under this appropriation we administer the processes supporting government grant funding schemes, from receiving applications to monitoring grant recipients.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
3,752 Revenue Crown 3,632 3,788 3,788
Revenue third parties 18
3,752 Total Revenue 3,650 3,788 3,788
3,588 Expenses 3,650 3,788 3,763
164 Net Surplus/(Deficit) 25

The increase in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates of $138,000 was due to an expense transfer from 2012/13 to 2013/14 for the Grants and Client Management Systems project (increase of $164,000). The increase was partially offset by the elimination of residual Kiwisaver and State Sector Retirement Savings Scheme expenditure (decrease of $18,000) and a realignment of funding based on the provision of services across the Vote Internal Affairs portfolios (decrease of $8,000).

Administration of Grants – Community

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Community Organisation Grants Scheme (COGS)
COGS grant applications are processed from receipt to payment within agreed timeframes At least 95% (of 4,600–5,300) New measure 96.2%
Distribution committee decisions are consistent with priorities, policies and procedures35 At least 95% of sample reviewed Achieved for 5% of each committee 100%
Distribution committee satisfaction with operational support received At least 80% received as ‘4’ or better New measure 98.4%
Crown Community Grants Schemes (excl COGS)
Grant applications processed from receipt to payment within agreed timeframes At least 95% (of 190–230) New measure Not achieved* (94% of 233)
Crown grant distribution committee decisions are consistent with priorities, policies and procedures At least 95% of sample reviewed New measure 95%
Activity Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Application levels for grant schemes (Other Expense Appropriations) administered:
  • Community Development Scheme ($5.072m)
  • Community Internship Programme ($231,000)
  • Digital Literacy and Connection ($3.723m)
  • Support for Volunteering ($502,000)
  • Youth Workers Training Scheme ($200,000)
Combined: 190–230 206 233
Community Organisation Grants Scheme ($12.500m) 4,600–5,300 5,28636 5,478

* This was a new measure for 2013/14 and the target of 95% was a stretch target. There were also difficulties in capturing the results accurately in our current system and it is likely the result is better than reported. These issues will be resolved with the introduction of a new Grants and Client Management System in October 2014 and with the valuable information gained this year we are confident the target will be met in 2014/15.

Back to top

Multi-Class Output Appropriation: Civic Information Services [MCOA]

Output Expense: Managing and Accessing Identity Information

Under this output expense we provide effective management of New Zealand’s records of identity including: issuing identity documents and New Zealand passports; processing citizenship applications; registering births, deaths, marriages and civil unions; developing authorised information-matching programmes with specified government agencies; providing data or data verification to government agencies to enable identity verification in a digital environment and to enhance border processes and facilitate travel; working across government to develop systems and processes for the verification and authentication of identity and to facilitate good practice based on Evidence of Identity Standard, and authenticating official documents, and coordinating the congratulatory message service.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
22,584 Revenue Crown 22,731 21,788 21,788
104,631 Revenue third parties 119,641 103,863 102,069
127,215 Total Revenue 142,372 125,651 123,857
127,064 Expenses 151,190 150,130 139,746
151 Net Surplus/(Deficit) (8,818) (24,479) (15,889)

The decrease in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates of $1.060 million was due to a realignment of funding based on the provision of services across the Vote Internal Affairs portfolios (decrease of $1.661 million) and a reduction in expenditure associated with the 2012 Passport fee reduction (decrease of $1.200 million). These decreases were partially offset by agency charges associated with RealMe (increase of $1.050 million), an expense transfer from 2012/13 to 2013/14 for amendments to the RealMe work programme (increase of $718,000) and demand for Authentication Services (increase of $33,000).

Actual expenditure was 7% lower than the Supplementary Estimates, primarily due to lower than anticipated expenditure associated with identity products. In addition, operating expenditure relating to several passport projects did not eventuate as the projects were deferred.

Citizenship

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Applications for grant of citizenship to foreign nationals recommended to the Minister within 100 days of receipt of correct applications At least 85% (of 21,000–25,000) 97.96% (of 27,609)37 97.24% (of 27,031)
Applications for registration of citizenship, not involving adoption, processed within 20 days of receipt of correct applications At least 95% (of 7,000–9,500) 97.17% (of 10,197) 98.86% (of 10,435)
Certificates of citizenship status issued within 15 days of receipt At least 95% (of 2,500–4,000) 95.98% (of 2,072) 100% (of 1,820)
Citizenship documents issued without error At least 95% (of 28,000–34,500) 99.67% (of 37,806) 99.69% (of 37,747)
Customer satisfaction with the citizenship service received At least 75% assessed as ‘3’ or better 89% 90%

Passports

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Passports, certificates and other travel documents issued without error At least 99% 99.95% 99.96%
Passports issued within stated timeframes of receipt of correct applications:

standard passports – within 10 days

At least 99% (of 549,000–619,000) 99.99% (of 570,506) 99.97% (of 591,051)

urgent passports – within 3 days

At least 99% (of 45,000–55,000) 99.95% (of 45,078) 99.84% (of 47,939)
Percentage of applications for adult passport renewals via the online service 35% New measure 36.02%
Customer satisfaction with the passport service received At least 75% assessed as ‘3’ or better 91% 91%

Births, Deaths, Marriages and Civil Unions

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Registration of birth, death, marriage and civil union information:

accuracy – issued without error

At least 99% 99.83% 99.52%

registration of death information will occur within the agreed timeframe on receipt of correct notification: 2 days

At least 99% 99.85% (of 30,163) 100% (of 30,030)

registration of birth information will occur within the agreed timeframe on receipt of correct notification: 8 days

At least 99% New measure 99% (of 59,978)
Birth, death, marriage and civil union certificates:

issued without error

At least 99% (of 220,000–250,000) 99.8% (of 268,010) 99.53% (of 264,540)
Birth, death, marriage and civil union certificates will be issued within the agreed timeframe on the receipt of a correct application: 5 days At least 99% 99.77% 100%
Birth, death, marriage and civil union printouts issued within 7 days of the receipt of correct application: At least 98% 99.88% 100%
Customer satisfaction with the birth, death, marriage and civil union service received38 At least 75% assessed as ‘3’ or better 90% 93%

Identity and Authentication Services

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Number of public and private RealMe services that are available for use:

logon

10 New measure 13

identity verification

2 New measure 4
Number of new RealMe accounts created:

account (verified)

50,000–100,000 New measure 15,212*

account (basic)

150,000–200,000 New measure 532,591
Clients are satisfied with the services provided At least 75% assessed as ‘3’ or better New measure 80%
Customers are satisfied with the RealMe services provided At least 75% assessed as ‘3’ or better New measure 87%

* The uptake of RealMe verified accounts has been lower than originally anticipated. New organisations only used RealMe for a short period during the 2013/14 year, and it was signalled in the January-March Quarter that this measure was unlikely to be achieved for 2013/14. No major government service has integrated the service (other than Elections, which went live on 30 June). As such, demand by customers to get a verified account has been limited.

Authentications Unit and Congratulatory Message Service

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Number of congratulatory message requests processed 1,100–1,200 New measure 1,797
Timeliness – delivered within agreed timeframes:

authentications

At least 98% (of 18,000–22,000) 99.9% (of 20,716) 100% (of 20,262)
Accuracy – authentication confirmations returned by customers as inaccurate No more than 1% 0.01% 0.07%

Output Expense: Managing and Accessing Knowledge Information

Under this output expense we manage public archives in both physical and digital formats on behalf of the Crown, provide public access to archives held by Archives New Zealand, provide services which assist access to library collections and other information, collect and preserve published and unpublished items for the National Library and Alexander Turnbull Library collections, provide library and information services and products to schools in support of the national curriculum, and administer the Public Lending Right for New Zealand Authors Scheme.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
80,964 Revenue Crown 82,748 84,924 84,924
7,185 Revenue third parties 7,297 7,850 7,148
88,149 Total Revenue 90,045 92,774 92,072
87,440 Expenses 89,918 92,720 96,740
709 Net Surplus/(Deficit) 127 54 (4,668)

The increase in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates of $2.802 million was due to capital charge as a result of asset revaluations in June 2013 (increase of $982,000), a realignment of funding based on the provision of services across the Vote Internal Affairs portfolios (increase of $767,000), demand for services provided by the National Library (increase of $220,000), digitisation work for Auckland libraries and other partners (increase of $200,000), Kotui shared library and resource discovery service (increase of $171,000), services provided by Archives New Zealand (increase of $100,000) and rental from retail and venue hire (increase of $47,000) and expense transfers from 2012/13 to 2013/14 for the National Library and Archives New Zealand Strategic Partnership Programme (increase of $285,000), the Government Digital Archive project (increase of $159,000) and the Digitisation of New Zealand Defence Force records (increase of $140,000). These increases were partially offset by a transfer of funding to the Emergency Management Services MCOA and the Community Information and Advisory Services MCOA to provide support for the development programme for Civil Defence and Emergency Management controllers and for the Ministry of Civil Defence and Emergency Management website redevelopment (decrease of $125,000), demand for Electronic Purchasing in Collaboration services (decrease of $112,000) and a transfer of funding to the Information and Technology Services MCOA to reflect the Department of Internal Affairs contribution towards Optimise HR (decrease of $32,000).

Actual expenditure was 4% higher than the Supplementary Estimates, primarily due to the impairment of two projects, Active Archives and Government Digital Archive.

National Archives – Managing Public Archives

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Number of transfers received from public offices completed (includes physical and digital) 60-80 71 74
Pages (or similar) of archives items digitised 400,000–500,000 706,462 1,773,378*
Storage environments maintained to required standards 24 hours a day, 7 days a week:

temperature

At least 80% 84.43% 93.9%**

relative humidity

At least 80% 76.64% 81.4%
Activity Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Archives held in storage: physical archives – linear metres (LM) 104,000–108,000 LM 104,227LM 105,748LM

* The target for pages digitised was exceeded by a large margin because there were more World War One service personnel files identified and these files were largely digitised in 2013/14 as there was a commitment to digitise all the World War One personnel files by the 100th anniversary of the start of the war in August. A programme largely using volunteer labour to digitise probate files is also underway and this provides additional resource at low cost for digitisation. This initiative will continue through 2014/15 which means that the target is likely to be exceeded in 2014/15 as well.

** The target for maintaining the storage environment – relative humidity was exceeded because there were more parts of the archive repositories that had stable environments through the year. There have been fewer parts of the repository that have not met the relative humidity standard as a result of work to address the environment for the parts of the repository where problems have been experienced in the past. There has been an improvement over the past two years to achieve and then exceed the target.

National Archives – Provision of Access to Public Archives

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Availability of online services 24 hours a day, 7 days a week At least 99% 97.79% 98.8%*
Number of items produced in public reading rooms 20,000–30,000 New measure 43,784**
Copies of archives newly made available online 30,000–50,000 13,986 78,467***

* Online services were available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week 98.8% of the time. Although there was a slight improvement in the final quarter, minimising system outages and scheduled maintenance downtime remains an issue.

** The number of items produced in public reading rooms exceeded the target range in 2013/14. The demand for items in the reading rooms is influenced by factors like the number of items available viewing online and the extent to which items are described and therefore easy to identify and request. The target for reading room items has been reduced in recent years as some heavily used groups of records are digitised and therefore will no longer attract reading room productions and because the Christchurch office had to reduce opening hours and delivery times due to damage caused by the 2011 earthquakes. The demand for items to be produced in the reading room has not dropped as much as expected however, which reflects that some groups of records have become easier to search for and request.

*** The target for the number of copies of archives newly made available online was exceeded because the number of items within the scope of digitisation initiatives was larger than the initially estimated, and a higher level of output was able to be achieved. This measure largely reflects the effort put into digitising a number of unit war diaries, the Chinese Poll Tax files, and the World War One service personnel files which were larger in numbers than had been anticipated.

National Library – Access to Information

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Requests (non-school) for the off-site supply of documents – completed within 2 days of receipt At least 90% (of 10,000–15,000) 98% (of 12,490) 99% (of 10,220)
Public Lending Right payments to all authors eligible for payment made within the timeframe stipulated by regulation 100% (of 1,800–1,900) 99% (of 1,702) Not achieved* (97% of 1,687)
Digitised items newly available for access online At least 450,000 660,535 472,540
Availability of online services 24 hours a day, 7 days a week 99% 99% 99%
Activity Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
New Zealand libraries participating in Te Puna (catalogue and interloan services) 92% (of 255–265) 91.4% (of 257) 92% (of 255)
Visits to National Library reading rooms 80,000–90,000 72,095 71,591
Availability of Te Puna catalogue and interloan services to subscribers during advertised hours At least 95% Revised 99%

* 1,634 authors were paid within the December 2013 timeline but database errors saw 53 authors not paid within the timeframe. They either have received or will receive their full payment for the 2013 registration year and the database errors will be addressed for the 2014 registration year.

National Library – Collecting and Preserving Information

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Of the acquisitions to the Alexander Turnbull Library (new heritage collections):

accession records for unpublished items completed within 10 days of receipt

At least 80% (of 1,000–1,500) 82% (of 8,329) 85% (of 1,107)

descriptive records for unpublished items added within 20 days of accession

At least 95% (of 1,000–1,500) 87% (of 8,329) 94% (of 1,240)*
‘At risk’ items digitised or digital formats transformed:

audio-visual items

At least 120 Revised 652**

images

At least 270 Revised 819**
Published acquisitions to the Alexander Turnbull Library (new heritage collections) 65,000–75,000 66,190 73,978
Microfilm frames of ‘at-risk’ newspapers created as part of the Newspaper Preservation Programme 250,000 250,795 256,040

* Priority has been given to improving the system in order to speed up the process and improve the quality of descriptive records, and performance is only 1% under standard. A procurement process for the replacement of the system to improve the quality of descriptive records is under way.

** There is considerable variability from year to year in the actual output for this measure, due to the unpredictability of the number and size of ‘at risk’ collection items curators identify that require digitisation or digital transfer. We sought to reflect a known minimum rather than a target maximum in the performance standard.

Activity Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Records added to the information system for unpublished items 18,000–28,000 37,172 31,301

National Library – Library and Information Services to Schools

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Requests for the supply of:

items from the schools collections met within 5 days of receipt

At least 75% (of 35,000–40,000) 84% (of 35,031) 77% (of 36,358)
Advisory support provided to targeted schools At least 75% (of 750–850) 83% (of 800) 76% (of 773)
Activity Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Items supplied on request from the schools collection 900,000–950,000 888,411 938,803
Visits to schools online services 150,000–180,000 New measure 243,378

Output Expense: Publishing Civic Information

Under this output expense we publish information through the New Zealand Gazette

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
Revenue Crown
930 Revenue third parties 844 937 876
930 Total Revenue 844 937 876
1,022 Expenses 850 1,018 1,015
(92) Net Surplus/(Deficit) (6) (81) (139)

The increase in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates of $168,000 was due to depreciation expenditure associated with the capitalisation of Gazette online.

New Zealand Gazette

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Accuracy – notices published consistent with text supplied by clients At least 99% (of 8,000–10,000) 99.99% (of 8,454) 99.98% (of 7,290)
Activity Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Issues of the New Zealand Gazette published each year 160 (1–140 pages each) 159 157*

* The reduction in demand for special supplement editions of the Gazette has resulted in a decrease in the overall number of editions for the year.

Back to top

Multi-Class Output Appropriation: Community Information and Advisory Services [MCOA]

Output Expense: Advisory and Information Services to Ethnic Communities

Under this output expense provision we provide advisory and information services to ethnic communities; management of the contract for the telephone interpreting service (Language Line); and provide information and training to ethnic communities and agencies using Language Line.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
4,025 Revenue Crown 3,455 4,134 4,134
1,238 Revenue third parties 1,291 1,356 1,382
5,263 Total Revenue 4,746 5,490 5,516
5,136 Expenses 4,746 5,490 5,530
127 Net Surplus/(Deficit) (14)

The increase in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates of $744,000 was due to a realignment of funding based on the provision of services across the Vote Internal Affairs portfolios (increase of $526,000), expense transfers from 2012/13 to 2013/14 for the Language Line promotional strategy and materials (increase of $105,000) and for an ongoing programme of initiatives to enable the transformation of systems and processes within the Department of Internal Affairs (increase of $22,000), the transfer of responsibility for the "Settling In" Programme from Vote Social Development with effect from 1 April 2014 (increase of $100,000) and a funding contribution towards the Ethnic People in Commerce project (increase of $65,000). These increases were partially offset by a transfer of funding to the Support for Statutory and Other Bodies MCOA to reflect a realignment of expenditure for the provision of secretariat support for the Chinese Poll Tax Heritage Trust (decrease of $74,000).

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Intercultural Awareness and Communication programme training sessions, including train the trainer, sessions held 15–20 (400–450 participants) 32 (457 participants) 15 (288 participants)
Forums and workshops for ethnic communities held 30–40 (600–650 participants) 42 (980 participants) 26 (969 participants)*
Respondent satisfaction with the quality of advisory services provided At least 95% assessed as ‘Satisfactory’ or better 96% 99%
Interpreting clients connected with an appropriate interpreter within 2 minutes of a call to Language Line At least 95% 98.91% (of 49,038) 98.57% (of 54,822)
Activity Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Agencies with agreements for the provision of telephone interpreting services through Language Line 85 96 100

* The number of forums and workshops is below the standard measure due to a clarification of the method of measurement. The standard was incorrectly set due to inclusion of additional activity that is not being reported for 2013/14.

Output Expense: Community Development and Engagement Advice

Under this output expense we provide advisory services to assist and guide community development activities and to assist government agencies to engage and interact with communities and community groups.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
5,692 Revenue Crown 4,969 4,884 4,884
Revenue third parties 38
5,692 Total Revenue 5,007 4,884 4,884
5,688 Expenses 5,007 4,884 4,767
4 Net Surplus/(Deficit) 117

The decrease in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates of $123,000 was due to a realignment of funding based on the provision of services across the Vote Internal Affairs portfolios (decrease of $89,000), the elimination of residual Kiwisaver and State Sector Retirement Savings Scheme expenditure (decrease of $29,000) and demand for the provision of services (decrease of $9,000). These decreases were partially offset by an expense transfer from 2012/13 to 2013/14 for an ongoing programme of initiatives to enable the transformation of systems and processes within the Department of Internal Affairs (increase of $4,000).

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Customer satisfaction with community advisory projects and activities:

advisory projects are considered effective

At least 85% New measure 78%*

other advisory activities are considered effective

At least 85% New measure 88%
Number of community advisory projects completed 45–55 53 89

* A standard of 85% is a stretch target for this measure, and a standard of 75% would be consistent with other customer satisfaction surveys run by the Department. Note that this is a small pool of thirty seven respondents, and 1 or 2 less positive responses can have a significant impact on overall results. 97% of respondents thought the service was somewhat effective or better.

Output Expense: Community Archives Support

Under this output expense we provide support for community, iwi and hapū organisations and other jurisdictions in preserving and managing their own records and archives and making them available.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
69 Revenue Crown 69 84 84
6 Revenue third parties 31 31 (5)
75 Total Revenue 100 115 79
123 Expenses 100 115 69
(48) Net Surplus/(Deficit) 10

The increase in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates of $15,000 was due to a realignment of funding based on the provision of services across the Vote Internal Affairs portfolios (increase of $15,000). Actual expenditure was 40% lower than the Supplementary Estimates, primarily due to lower provision of services to third parties and accordingly, lower expenditure associated with the provision of services.

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Availability of the online descriptive tool 24 hours a day, 7 days a week At least 99% 99.8% 99.59%

Output Expense: Community Information – Civil Defence Emergency Management

Under this output expense we develop and deliver long-term national programmes to raise individual and community awareness and preparedness.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
1,611 Revenue Crown 1,331 1,131 1,131
26 Revenue third parties 23 89 89
1,637 Total Revenue 1,354 1,220 1,220
1,570 Expenses 1,354 1,220 1,220
67 Net Surplus/(Deficit)

The decrease in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates of $134,000 was due to the transfer of Ministry of Civil Defence and Emergency Management functions and associated funding to Vote Prime Minister and Cabinet with effect from 1 April 2014 (decrease of $310,000). The decrease was partially offset by a realignment of funding based on the provision of services across the Vote Internal Affairs portfolios (increase of $75,000), the provision of services to the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade for disaster risk management support for the United Nations Office of the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs and disaster risk management support for Pacific Island countries (increase of $75,000), an expense transfer from 2012/13 to 2013/14 for an ongoing programme of initiatives to enable the transformation of systems and processes within the Department of Internal Affairs (increase of $19,000) and a transfer of funding from the Civic Information Services MCOA to provide support for the development programme for Civil Defence and Emergency Management controllers and for the Ministry of Civil Defence and Emergency Management website redevelopment (increase of $7,000).

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/1439
Advertising reaches the targeted audience demographic (assessed quarterly): television – at least 70% Achieved – for at least 3 quarters Not achieved

Q1: 82%

Q2: 0%*

Q3: 70%

Advertising reaches the targeted audience demographic (assessed quarterly): radio – at least 45% Achieved – for at least 3 quarters Not achieved Not achieved**
Availability of the civil defence website 24 hours a day, 7 days a week At least 99.9% 99.91% 99.65%

* There was no television advertising in Q2 due to finanical constraints.

** Although some local CDEM groups maintained radio advertising, all funding for national radio advertising was channelled into television, due to financial constraints.

Appropriation: Contestable Services [RDA]

Under this appropriation we provide translation and other language services to government agencies and the public, and support services to government agencies.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
Revenue Crown
896 Revenue third parties 900 1,010 1,050
896 Total Revenue 900 1,010 1,050
888 Expenses 900 1,010 1,026
8 Net Surplus/(Deficit) 24

The increase in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates of $110,000 was due to an increase in demand for Translation Services.

Translation Services

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Translations provided within timeframes agreed with service providers At least 99% (of 6,500–7,500) 99.45% (of 8,050) 99.33% (of 6,095)
Customer satisfaction with the quality of translation services provided40 Assessed as ‘Satisfied’ or better (at least 99%) 95% 94.37%*

* This performance standard was unrealistic and has been changed for 2014/15 to align with Citizenship and BDM customer satisfaction measures, as translations are often undertaken to support these processes. The new standard for 2014/15 is – at least 85% as Satisfied or better.

Back to top

Multi Class Output Appropriation: Emergency Management Services [MCOA]

Output Expense: Management of National Emergency Readiness, Response and Recovery

Under this output expense we manage national emergency readiness, response and recovery, including: support to local civil defence emergency management organisations, maintaining the National Crisis Management Centre in a state of readiness, national training and education, coordination and management of central government’s response and recovery activities and administration of related expenses.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
3,961 Revenue Crown 3,736 2,863 2,863
97 Revenue third parties 86 333 333
4,058 Total Revenue 3,822 3,196 3,196
4,235 Expenses 3,822 3,196 3,196
(177) Net Surplus/(Deficit)

The decrease in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates of $626,000 was due to the transfer of Ministry of Civil Defence and Emergency Management functions and associated funding to Vote Prime Minister and Cabinet with effect from 1 April 2014 (decrease of $858,000) and a realignment of funding based on the provision of services across the Vote Internal Affairs portfolios (decrease of $166,000). These decreases were partially offset by the provision of services to the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade for disaster risk management support for the United Nations Office of the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs and disaster risk management support for Pacific Island countries (increase of $281,000), a transfer of funding from the Civic Information Services MCOA to provide support for the development programme for Civil Defence and Emergency Management controllers and for the Ministry of Civil Defence and Emergency Management website redevelopment (increase of $62,000) and an expense transfer from 2012/13 to 2013/14 for an ongoing programme of initiatives to enable the transformation of systems and processes within the Department of Internal Affairs (increase of $55,000).

Management of National Emergency Management Readiness, Response and Recovery

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/1441
National Warning System tests conducted At least 4 (1 test per quarter) 4 3 (1 test in each quarter)
National warnings issued within 30 minutes after the notification of a pending event that exceeds the thresholds All (of 1–6) All (of 1) All (of 2)
National warning distribution list – accuracy of contact details (at each warning or test) At least 95% 96% 96.7%
Stakeholder satisfaction with the timing and content of national warning messages Assessed as ‘Satisfied’ or better by at least 85% (of 200) 63% Annual measure at Q4
National Crisis Management Centre (NCMC) managed, during activations, with:

staffing in place according to the activation mode within 2 hours

All All All

essential information technology systems available and operating at agreed performance levels

All Not achieved All

back-up information technology systems and equipment fully functional

At least 99.8% 100% 100%

coordination and management consistent with the Response Concept of Operations for extended activations

All (no variations) No extended activations in 12/13 No extended activations
National Crisis Management Centre activations reviewed:

mode 2 or higher activations – within 3 months

All All (1 review) All (1 review)

approved recommendations (lessons identified) actioned – within set timeframes

All All All

Output Expense: Emergency Sector Support and Development

Under this output expense we develop and implement operational policies and projects, advice, assistance and information to the civil defence and emergency management sector.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
3,877 Revenue Crown 3,711 2,910 2,910
136 Revenue third parties 121 467 467
4,013 Total Revenue 3,832 3,377 3,377
3,721 Expenses 3,832 3,377 3,377
292 Net Surplus/(Deficit)

The decrease in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates of $455,000 was due to the transfer of Ministry of Civil Defence and Emergency Management functions and associated funding to Vote Prime Minister and Cabinet with effect from 1 April 2014 (decrease of $1.074 million). The decrease was partially offset by the provision of services to the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade for disaster risk management support for the United Nations Office of the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs and disaster risk management support for Pacific Island countries (increase of $394,000), a realignment of funding based on the provision of services across the Vote Internal Affairs portfolios (increase of $161,000), a transfer of funding from the Civic Information Services MCOA to provide support for the development programme for Civil Defence and Emergency Management controllers and for the Ministry of Civil Defence and Emergency Management website redevelopment (increase of $56,000) and an expense transfer from 2012/13 to 2013/14 for an ongoing programme of initiatives to enable the transformation of systems and processes within the Department of Internal Affairs (increase of $8,000).

Emergency Sector Support and Development

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/1442
Director Guidelines, Technical Standards, Codes and other CDEM sector information publications maintained – currently reviewed at least every 4 years 4–7 (of 25) 4 4
Satisfaction, assessed as ‘Good’ or ‘Very Good’, in relation to:

CDEM Group – coverage of the Guidelines, Technical Standards and Codes and other publications43

At least 80% (of est 100) 64% Annual measure at Q4

CDEM Group – quality of the Guidelines, Technical Standards and Codes and other publications

At least 80% (of est 100) 73% Annual measure at Q4

the quality of the newsletters/updates – 16–20 issues44

At least 80% (of 200) 67% Annual measure at Q4
Attendee satisfaction with civil defence and emergency management training courses At least 90% (of 120–150) 93% (of 140) 80%* (of 120)

* No courses were run in Q1 or Q3 – MCDEM is reviewing the workshops in view of the Q2 rating.

Output Appropriation: Film Archive Services RDA

This appropriation is limited to expenses incurred in provision of film preservation and processing services to film archival and production organisations.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
Revenue Crown
Revenue third parties 100
Total Revenue 100
Expenses 100
Net Surplus/(Deficit)

This appropriation was established in 2013/14 to recognise the provision of film preservation and processing services to film archival and production organisations (increase of $100,000).

The laboratory required to provide film preservation and processing services is under construction and accordingly no services were provided in 2013/14.

Performance Information

Activity for 2013/14 financial year consisted of developing and setting up this function. Services will commence in the 2014/15 financial year. Performance measures have been developed and will be reported on in the 2014/15 Annual Report.

Back to top

Multi-Class Output Appropriation: Information and Technology Services [MCOA]

Output Expense: Cross-Government ICT Strategy and Planning, Service Delivery and Investment Proposals

Under this output expense we develop all-of-government ICT strategy and planning, develop and support integrated service delivery programmes, investment proposals relating to potential cross-government common services, common ICT capability initiatives, and detailed business cases for selected initiatives to inform investment decisions by Ministers.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
7,224 Revenue Crown 5,878 13,291 13,291
Revenue third parties 2,400 2,495 2,494
7,224 Total Revenue 8,278 15,786 15,785
6,639 Expenses 8,278 15,786 13,498
585 Net Surplus/(Deficit) 2,287

The increase in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates of $7.508 million was due to funding for the progression of four initiatives, namely Result 10, ICT Contact Centre Optimisation, ICT nz.govt.nz redevelopment and ICT Government Online Engagement Services (increase of $4.750 million), funding for the Government Chief Information Officer to provide coordinated oversight and delivery of system-wide ICT assurance (increase of $1.500 million), expense transfers from 2012/13 to 2013/14 for ICT Functional Leadership (increase of $480,000), Result 10: Smart Digital Services programme (increase of $400,000) and Optimise HR (increase of $52,000), a realignment of funding based on the provision of services across the Vote Internal Affairs portfolios (increase of $199,000), Club Funding contributions from lead agencies for Optimise HR (increase of $95,000) and a transfer of funding from the Civic Information Services MCOA to reflect the Department of Internal Affairs contribution towards Optimise HR (increase of $32,000).

Actual expenditure was 14% lower than the Supplementary Estimates, primarily due to delays in implementation of Functional Leadership of Government ICT initiatives, Result 10: Virtual Citizen Account and Child Support/Sole Parent projects and the ICT – newzealand.govt.nz Redevelopment project. In-principle expense transfers from 2013/14 to 2014/15 up to a maximum of $1.560 million were approved for delays associated with these projects.

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Actions due for delivery in 2013/14 in the “Government 2017: ICT Strategy and Action Plan” for which DIA is the lead agency, are delivered Actions delivered New measure Achieved
Blueprint to deliver Result 10 developed and endorsed Achieved New measure Achieved
Digital Service Council satisfied with the quality of advice and support received Assessed as ‘Satisfied’ or better New measure Achieved
Activity Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Advice and support services provided to the Digital Service Council, with regular meetings organised 10–14 meetings New measure 14 meetings held

Output Expense: Government Information and Technology Services

Under this output expense we develop, deploy and operate technology services across the State sector.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
7,677 Revenue Crown 6,099 8,820 8,820
3,415 Revenue third parties 6,023 2,817 1,840
11,092 Total Revenue 12,122 11,637 10,660
13,768 Expenses 12,868 17,059 13,452
(2,676) Net Surplus/(Deficit) (746) (5,422) (2,792)

The increase in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates of $4.191 million was due to expense transfers from 2012/13 to 2013/14 for Infrastructure as a Service Transition (increase of $1.000 million), the Government Information Services Online programme (increase of $400,000) and an ongoing programme of initiatives to enable the transformation of systems and processes within the Department of Internal Affairs (increase of $164,000), funding for the progression of the Software Acquisition Strategy (increase of $1.505 million), a funding contribution from the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment for work associated with Telecommunications as a Service (increase of $670,000), the provision of services by the Government Chief Information Officer to government agencies (increase of $500,000) and an increase in expenditure associated with Government Common Capability products (increase of $300,000). These increases were partially offset by a realignment of funding based on the provision of services across the Vote Internal Affairs portfolios (decrease of $348,000).

Actual expenditure was 21% lower than the Supplementary Estimates, primarily due to delays in the Government Information Services Online Programme, Infrastructure as a Service Transition and the Software Acquisition Strategy. In-principle expense transfers from 2013/14 to 2014/15 up to a maximum of $1.655 million were approved for delays associated with these projects.

Government Technology Services

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
All-of-government Common Capability products, where DIA is the lead agency, meet service level agreements Achieved New measure Achieved

Government Information Services

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Availability of cross-government online services, 24 hours a day, 7 days a week 99% 99.87% Achieved (99.56%)

Output Expense: Government Chief Privacy Officer

Under this output expense we develop and implement an all-of-government approach to privacy, including liaising with the regulator, developing and promulgating privacy standards for the public sector, supporting and working with agencies to build capability, and providing assurance on public sector performace in relation to privacy.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
Revenue Crown 463 463
Revenue third parties
Total Revenue 463 463
Expenses 463 262
Net Surplus/(Deficit) 201

The increase in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates of $463,000 was due to the establishment of a Government Chief Privacy Officer in the Department of Internal Affairs, with responsibility for privacy leadership across government.

Actual expenditure was 43% lower than the Supplementary Estimates, primarily due to the timing of staff recruitment.

Performance Information

Activity for 2013/14 financial year consisted of developing and setting up this function. Services will commence in the 2014/15 financial year. Performance measures have been developed and will be reported on in the 2014/15 Annual Report.

Appropriation: Local Government Services

Under this appropriation we provide information to and about local government, administering the Local Government Act 2002 and other statutes, administer the Local Electoral Act 2001, administer the Rates Rebate Scheme, provide regulatory and boating services for Lake Taupo (including providing the Harbourmaster and managing the Lake Taupo Landing Reserve); and govern and manage the National Dog Control Information Database.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
2,036 Revenue Crown 1,931 1,892 1,892
786 Revenue third parties 1,062 922 782
2,822 Total Revenue 2,993 2,814 2,674
2,781 Expenses 2,611 2,572 2,364
41 Net Surplus/(Deficit) 382 242 310

The decrease in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates of $39,000 was due to a realignment of funding based on the provision of services across the Vote Internal Affairs portfolios.

Actual expenditure was 8% lower than the Supplementary Estimates, primarily due to lower than anticipated personnel costs associated with the lower use of contractors.

Local Government Services

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Responses to requests for information about the Rates Rebate Scheme within 10 days of receipt At least 98% (of 300–600) 99% (of 444) 100% (of 501)
Eligible claims from councils for reimbursement of rates rebates processed within 30 days of receipt At least 95% (of 110,000–120,000) New measure 99.94% (of 105,622)
National Dogs Database snapshot statistics for the year as at May made available to the public by June Achieved New measure Not Achieved*

* The Department was not able to upload the data prior to the June deadline because the third party supplier of the data had mistakenly scheduled a later date to generate the data spreadsheet. The provider is now aware of when the data is required and there are no problems anticipated for 2014/15.

Regulatory and Boating Services for Lake Taupo

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Boating facilities and navigational safety equipment inspected in accordance with an annual compliance programme All All All
Customer satisfaction with the quality of Lake Taupo navigational safety services assessed as average or above, when surveyed every 2 years (next survey 2015) At least 85% Changed – measure was 100% No survey*

* No survey was completed in the 2013/14 year. The next survey will be in 2015.

Output Appropriation: Machinery of Government Transition Costs

This appropriation is limited to transition costs related to implementing Machinery of Government decisions.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
Revenue Crown 710 710
Revenue third parties
Total Revenue 710 710
Expenses 710 679
Net Surplus/(Deficit) 31

This previously existing appropriation was re-established in 2013/14 to reflect the transition and stranded overhead costs associated with the transfer of Ministry of Civil Defence and Emergency Management functions to Vote Prime Minister and Cabinet.

Multi-Class Output Appropriation: Ministerial Support Services [MCOA]

Output Expense: Ministerial Support Services – Crown Entity Monitoring

Under this output expense we provide support, information and advice to Ministers to enable them to discharge their responsibilities (other than policy decision-making) for the Crown entities for which they are responsible.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
847 Revenue Crown 1,000 969 969
Revenue third parties
847 Total Revenue 1,000 969 969
675 Expenses 1,000 969 730
172 Net Surplus/(Deficit) 239

The decrease in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates of $31,000 was due to a realignment of funding based on the provision of services across the Vote Internal Affairs portfolios.

Actual expenditure was 25% lower than the Supplementary Estimates, primarily due to lower than anticipated levels of personnel expenditure.

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Advice on accountability and performance documents delivered within statutory or agreed timeframes (based on delivery of documents to the Minister by the Crown entity) 100% (estimated volume 12–17) New measure 100% (of 14)
Appointment processes for board vacancies managed consistent with the approach agreed with the Minister (including amendments agreed with the Minister) 100% (estimated volume 2–4) All (of 8) 100% (of 4)
Activity Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Crown Entities monitored:

New Zealand Fire Service Commission

Office of Film and Literature Classification

Output Expense: Ministerial Support Services – Community and Voluntary Sector

Under this output expense we provide services to Ministers to enable them to discharge their portfolio (other than policy decision-making) responsibilities relating to the community and voluntary sector.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
151 Revenue Crown 153 185 185
Revenue third parties
151 Total Revenue 153 185 185
174 Expenses 153 185 204
(23) Net Surplus/(Deficit) (19)

The increase in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates of $32,000 was due to a realignment of funding based on the provision of services across the Vote Internal Affairs portfolios.

Actual expenditure was 10% higher than the Supplementary Estimates, primarily due to higher than anticipated personnel costs due to vacant positions being covered by contractors.

Ministerial Correspondence and Questions

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Acceptance of first draft responses to ministerials and information briefings presented to the Minister At least 95% Not measured 100% (of 26)
Required timeframes are met: parliamentary questions (written) – within 3 days of notification or as agreed with the Minister At least 95% (of 20–30) Not measured 100% (of 3)
Required timeframes are met: ministerial correspondence (draft responses) – within 15 days of receipt or as specifically agreed At least 95% (of 30–50) Not measured 100% (of 9)
Required timeframes are met: Official Information and Privacy Act requests, and Ombudsmen inquiries – at least 5 days prior to statutory timeframes At least 95% (of 0–10) Not measured 100% (of 1)

Output Expense: Ministerial Support Services – Emergency Management

Under this output expense we provide services to Ministers to enable them to discharge their portfolio (other than policy decision-making) responsibilities relating to civil defence and emergency management.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
189 Revenue Crown 210 240 240
Revenue third parties
189 Total Revenue 210 240 240
254 Expenses 210 240 240
(65) Net Surplus/(Deficit)

The increase in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates of $30,000 was due to a realignment of funding based on the provision of services across the Vote Internal Affairs portfolios (increase of $117,000). The increase was partially offset by the transfer of Ministry of Civil Defence and Emergency Management functions and associated funding to Vote Prime Minister and Cabinet with effect from 1 April 2014 (decrease of $87,000).

Ministerial Correspondence and Questions

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/1445
Acceptance of first draft responses to ministerials and information briefings presented to the Minister At least 95% Not measured 100% (of 42)
Required timeframes are met: parliamentary questions (written) – within 3 days of notification or as agreed with the Minister At least 95% (of 20–30) Not measured 100% (of 17)
Required timeframes are met: ministerial correspondence (draft responses) within 15 days of receipt or as specifically agreed At least 95% (of 30–50) Not measured 100% (of 33)
Required timeframes are met: Official Information and Privacy Act requests, and Ombudsmen inquiries – at least 5 days prior to statutory timeframes At least 95% (of 0–10) Not measured 100% (of 2)

Output Expense: Ministerial Support Services – Ethnic Affairs

Under this output expense we provide services to Ministers to enable them to discharge their portfolio (other than policy decision-making) responsibilities relating to ethnic affairs.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
89 Revenue Crown 87 87 87
Revenue third parties
89 Total Revenue 87 87 87
97 Expenses 87 87 96
(8) Net Surplus/(Deficit) (9)

The increase in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates was due to an expense transfer from 2012/13 to 2013/14 for an ongoing programme of initiatives to enable the transformation of systems and processes within the Department of Internal Affairs (increase of $1,000) offset by a realignment of funding based on the provision of services across the Vote Internal Affairs portfolios (decrease of ($1000).

Ministerial Correspondence and Questions

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Acceptance of first draft responses to ministerials and information briefings presented to the Minister At least 95% Not measured 100%
Required timeframes are met: parliamentary questions (written) – within 3 days of notification or as agreed with the Minister At least 95% (of 5–10) Not measured 100% (of 4)
Required timeframes are met: ministerial correspondence (draft responses) – within 15 days of receipt or as specifically agreed At least 95% (of 10–20) Not measured 100% (of 14)
Required timeframes are met: Official Information and Privacy Act requests, and Ombudsmen inquiries – at least 5 days prior to statutory timeframes At least 95% (of 1–5) Not measured 100% (of 2)

Output Expense: Ministerial Support Services – Internal Affairs

Under this output expense we provide services to Ministers to enable them to discharge their portfolio (other than policy decision-making) responsibilities relating to internal affairs, including regulatory and identity matters, all-of-government information and communications technology, the role of information in New Zealand’s cultural and economic life, public recordkeeping and the management of national archives, and other areas that fall within the internal affairs portfolio.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
379 Revenue Crown 379 420 420
Revenue third parties
379 Total Revenue 379 420 420
326 Expenses 379 420 405
53 Net Surplus/(Deficit) 15

The increase in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates of $41,000 was due to a realignment of funding based on the provision of services across the Vote Internal Affairs portfolios (increase of $38,000) and an expense transfer from 2012/13 to 2013/14 for an ongoing programme of initiatives to enable the transformation of systems and processes within the Department of Internal Affairs (increase of $3,000).

Ministerial Correspondence and Questions

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Acceptance of first draft responses to ministerials and information briefings presented to the Minister At least 95% Not measured 100% (of 340)
Required timeframes are met: parliamentary questions (written) – within 3 days of notification or as agreed with the Minister At least 95% (of 40–70) Not measured 100% (of 46)
Required timeframes are met: ministerial correspondence (draft responses) – within 15 days of receipt or as specifically agreed At least 95% (of 300–400) Not measured 100% (of 321)
Required timeframes are met: Official Information and Privacy Act requests, and Ombudsmen inquiries – at least 5 days prior to statutory timeframes At least 95% (of 30–50) Not measured 100% (of 12)

Output Expense: Ministerial Support Services – Local Government

Under this output expense we provide services to Ministers to enable them to discharge their portfolio (other than policy decision-making) responsibilities relating to local government.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
295 Revenue Crown 291 511 511
Revenue third parties
295 Total Revenue 291 511 511
352 Expenses 291 511 532
(57) Net Surplus/(Deficit) (21)

The increase in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates of $220,000 was due to a realignment of funding based on the provision of services across the Vote Internal Affairs portfolios (increase of $218,000) and an expense transfer from 2012/13 to 2013/14 for an ongoing programme of initiatives to enable the transformation of systems and processes within the Department of Internal Affairs (increase of $2,000).

Ministerial Correspondence and Questions

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Acceptance of first draft responses to ministerials and information briefings presented to the Minister At least 95% Not measured 100% (of 460)
Required timeframes are met: parliamentary questions (written) – within 3 days of notification or as agreed with the Minister At least 95% (of 15–35) Not measured 100% (of 115)
Required timeframes are met: ministerial correspondence (draft responses) – within 15 days of receipt or as specifically agreed At least 95% (of 900–1,000) Not measured 99.75% (of 405)
Required timeframes are met: Official Information and Privacy Act requests, and Ombudsmen inquiries – at least 5 days prior to statutory timeframes At least 95% (of 30–50) Not measured 100% (of 24)

Output Expense: Ministerial Support Services – Ministerial Services

Under this output expense we provide services to Ministers to enable them to discharge their portfolio (other than policy decision-making) responsibilities relating to Ministerial Services.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
200 Revenue Crown 203 208 208
Revenue third parties
200 Total Revenue 203 208 208
175 Expenses 203 208 194
25 Net Surplus/(Deficit) 14

The increase in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates of $5,000 was due to a realignment of funding based on the provision of services across the Vote Internal Affairs portfolios.

Actual expenditure was 7% lower than the Supplementary Estimates, primarily due to lower expenditure on staff training.

Ministerial Correspondence and Questions

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Acceptance of first draft responses presented to the Minister At least 95% 100% 100%
Parliamentary questions (written and oral) – within 3 days of notification or as agreed with the Minister At least 95% (of 60–120) New measure 90%* (of 114)
Ministerial correspondence (draft responses) – within 15 days of receipt or as specifically agreed At least 95% (of 5–15) New measure 100% (of 7)
Official Information and Privacy Act requests, and Ombudsmen inquiries – at least 5 days prior to statutory timeframes At least 95% (of 70–120) New measure 98% (of 65)
Information briefings delivered to agreed quality criteria and standards – demonstrated through independent assessment Agreed quality criteria and standards met Achieved Achieved
Information briefings delivered to agreed timeframes At least 95% (of 5–15) New measure 100%
Activity Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Information briefings and responses required for correspondence, information and parliamentary questions 140-270 169 187

* During the first quarter, 11 written parliamentary questions were not submitted in time due to an issue with the reliability of data.

Output Expense: Ministerial Support Services – Racing

Under this output expense we provide services to Ministers to enable them to discharge their portfolio (other than policy decision-making) responsibilities relating to racing.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
47 Revenue Crown 48 60 60
Revenue third parties
47 Total Revenue 48 60 60
51 Expenses 48 60 57
(4) Net Surplus/(Deficit) 3

The increase in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates of $12,000 was due to a realignment of funding based on the provision of services across the Vote Internal Affairs portfolios (increase of $11,000) and an expense transfer from 2012/13 to 2013/14 for an ongoing programme of initiatives to enable the transformation of systems and processes within the Department of Internal Affairs (increase of $1,000).

Ministerial Correspondence and Questions

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Acceptance of first draft responses presented to ministerials and information briefings presented to the Minister At least 95% New measure 100% (of 74)
Required timeframes are met: parliamentary questions (written) – within 3 days of notification or as agreed with the Minister At least 95% (of 0–10) New measure Not measured*
Required timeframes are met: ministerial correspondence (draft responses) – within 15 days of receipt or as specifically agreed At least 95% (of 40–70) New measure 100% (of 64)
Official Information and Privacy Act requests, and Ombudsmen inquiries – at least 5 days prior to statutory timeframes At least 95% (of 0–10) New measure 100% (of 4)

* No written parliamentary questions were received in the Racing portfolio during 2013/14.

Multi-Class Output Appropriation: Policy Advice [MCOA]

Output Expense: Policy Advice – Community and Voluntary Sector

Under this output expense we provide advice (including second opinion advice and contributions to policy advice led by other agencies) to support decision making by Ministers on government policy matters relating to the community and voluntary sector.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
1,747 Revenue Crown 1,190 649 649
Revenue third parties
1,747 Total Revenue 1,190 649 649
1,041 Expenses 1,190 649 583
706 Net Surplus/(Deficit) 66

The decrease in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates of $541,000 was due to a realignment of funding based on the provision of services across the Vote Internal Affairs portfolios (decrease of $563,000). The decrease was partially offset by an expense transfer from 2012/13 to 2013/14 for an ongoing programme of initiatives to enable the transformation of systems and processes within the Department of Internal Affairs (increase of $22,000).

Actual expenditure was 10% lower than the Supplementary Estimates, primarily due to lower than anticipated personnel costs resulting from delays in filling vacancies.

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Policy advice and policy briefings delivered to agreed quality criteria and standards – demonstrated through independent assessment Agreed quality criteria and standards met Achieved Achieved
Minister’s satisfaction with the quality of policy advice (quarterly) Assessed as ‘Satisfied’ or better

Q1: Satisfied

Q2: Good

Q3: Good

Q4: Good

Q1–2: 9*

Q3–4: 9

Total cost of an hour of professional staff time devoted to policy unit outputs. $90–$120 New measure $99.02
Total cost of an hour of professional staff time devoted to policy unit outputs (updated**). N/A $137.78

* In 2013/14 we changed the way we collect information for this measure. In accordance with the Treasury Common Policy Indicators Report Data Collection Guidelines, we now undertake surveys on a 6 monthly basis, using a standardised Ministerial Satisfaction Survey format. The different satisfaction results align as follows: Very Poor (1–2), Poor (3–4), Satisfactory (5–6), Good (7–8), Very Good (9–10).

** The TCPOH formula has recently been updated by Treasury to better align it with the amended definition of policy advice costs. Performance measures calculated using both the original and updated formulae have been provided to help readers understand how this change has affected the assessment of performance. Both formulae are shown below.

TCPOH formula
Total cost per
output hour
Original formula Updated formula
Total Policy Advice Costs Total Policy Advice Costs
Total Policy Output and
Non-Policy Output Hours
Total Policy Output Hours
(excluding non-policy advice hours)

Output Expense: Policy Advice – Emergency Management

Under this output expense we provide advice (including second opinion advice and contributions to policy advice led by other agencies) to support decision-making by Ministers on government policy matters relating to civil defence and emergency management.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
715 Revenue Crown 704 431 431
Revenue third parties
715 Total Revenue 704 431 431
582 Expenses 704 431 431
133 Net Surplus/(Deficit)

The decrease in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates of $273,000 was due to the transfer of Ministry of Civil Defence and Emergency Management functions and associated funding to Vote Prime Minister and Cabinet with effect from 1 April 2014 (decrease of $139,000) and a realignment of funding based on the provision of services across the Vote Internal Affairs portfolios (decrease of $134,000).

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Policy advice and policy briefings delivered to agreed quality criteria and standards – demonstrated through independent assessment Agreed quality criteria and standards met Achieved Achieved
Minister’s satisfaction with the quality of policy advice (quarterly) Assessed as ‘Satisfied’ or better

Q1: Good

Q2: Good

Q3: Satisfied

Q4: Satisfied

Q1–2: 7*

Q3–4: 7

Total cost of an hour of professional staff time devoted to policy unit outputs. $90–$120 New measure $99.02
Total cost of an hour of professional staff time devoted to policy unit outputs (updated**). N/A $137.78

* In 2013/14 we changed the way we collect information for this measure. In accordance with the Treasury Common Policy Indicators Report Data Collection Guidelines, we now undertake surveys on a 6 monthly basis, using a standardised Ministerial Satisfaction Survey format. The different satisfaction results align as follows: Very Poor (1–2), Poor (3–4), Satisfactory (5–6), Good (7–8), Very Good (9–10).

** The TCPOH formula has recently been updated by Treasury to better align it with the amended definition of policy advice costs. Performance measures calculated using both the original and updated formulae have been provided to help readers understand how this change has affected the assessment of performance. Both formulae are shown below.

TCPOH formula
Total cost per
output hour
Original formula Updated formula
Total Policy Advice Costs Total Policy Advice Costs
Total Policy Output and
Non-Policy Output Hours
Total Policy Output Hours
(excluding non-policy advice hours)

Output Expense: Policy Advice – Ethnic Affairs

Under this output expense we provide advice (including second opinion advice and contributions to policy advice led by other agencies) to support decision making by Ministers on government policy matters relating to ethnic affairs.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
752 Revenue Crown 762 782 782
Revenue third parties
752 Total Revenue 762 782 782
722 Expenses 762 782 745
30 Net Surplus/(Deficit) 37

The increase in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates of $20,000 was due to a realignment of funding based on the provision of services across the Vote Internal Affairs portfolios.

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Policy advice and policy briefings delivered to agreed quality criteria and standards – demonstrated through independent assessment Agreed quality criteria and standards met Achieved Achieved
Minister’s satisfaction with the quality of policy advice (quarterly) Assessed as ‘Satisfied’ or better

Q1: Very Good

Q2: Very Good

Q3: Good

Q4: Very Good

Q1–2: 9*

Q3–4: 9

Total cost of an hour of professional staff time devoted to policy unit outputs. $90–$120 New measure $99.02
Total cost of an hour of professional staff time devoted to policy unit outputs (updated**). N/A $137.78

* In 2013/14 we changed the way we collect information for this measure. In accordance with the Treasury Common Policy Indicators Report Data Collection Guidelines, we now undertake surveys on a 6 monthly basis, using a standardised Ministerial Satisfaction Survey format. The different satisfaction results align as follows: Very Poor (1–2), Poor (3–4), Satisfactory (5–6), Good (7–8), Very Good (9–10).

** The TCPOH formula has recently been updated by Treasury to better align it with the amended definition of policy advice costs. Performance measures calculated using both the original and updated formulae have been provided to help readers understand how this change has affected the assessment of performance. Both formulae are shown below.

TCPOH formula
Total cost per
output hour
Original formula Updated formula
Total Policy Advice Costs Total Policy Advice Costs
Total Policy Output and
Non-Policy Output Hours
Total Policy Output Hours
(excluding non-policy advice hours)

Output Expense: Policy Advice – Internal Affairs

Under this output expense we provide advice (including second opinion advice and contributions to policy advice led by other agencies) to support decision making by Ministers on government policy matters relating to internal affairs, including regulatory and identity matters, all-of-government information and communications technology, the role of information in New Zealand’s cultural and economic life, public recordkeeping and the management of national archives, and other areas that fall within the internal affairs portfolio.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
3,746 Revenue Crown 3,911 4,424 4,424
2 Revenue third parties 36 36
3,748 Total Revenue 3,947 4,460 4,424
4,046 Expenses 3,947 4,460 4,280
(298) Net Surplus/(Deficit) 144

The increase in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates of $513,000 was due to a realignment of funding based on the provision of services across the Vote Internal Affairs portfolios (increase of $596,000). The increase was partially offset by a transfer of funding to The Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet for a National Cyber Policy position (decrease of $83,000).

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Policy advice and policy briefings delivered to agreed quality criteria and standards – demonstrated through independent assessment Agreed quality criteria and standards met Achieved Achieved
Minister’s satisfaction with the quality of policy advice (quarterly) Assessed as ‘Satisfied’ or better

Q1: Very Good

Q2: Very Good

Q3: Very Good

Q4: Good to Very Good

Q1–2: 9*

Q3–4: 8

Total cost of an hour of professional staff time devoted to policy unit outputs. $90–$120 New measure $99.02
Total cost of an hour of professional staff time devoted to policy unit outputs (updated**). N/A $137.78

* In 2013/14 we changed the way we collect information for this measure. In accordance with the Treasury Common Policy Indicators Report Data Collection Guidelines, we now undertake surveys on a 6 monthly basis, using a standardised Ministerial Satisfaction Survey format. The different satisfaction results align as follows: Very Poor (1–2), Poor (3–4), Satisfactory (5–6), Good (7–8), Very Good (9–10).

** The TCPOH formula has recently been updated by Treasury to better align it with the amended definition of policy advice costs. Performance measures calculated using both the original and updated formulae have been provided to help readers understand how this change has affected the assessment of performance. Both formulae are shown below.

TCPOH formula
Total cost per
output hour
Original formula Updated formula
Total Policy Advice Costs Total Policy Advice Costs
Total Policy Output and
Non-Policy Output Hours
Total Policy Output Hours
(excluding non-policy advice hours)

Output Expense: Policy Advice – Local Government

Under this output expense we provide advice (including second opinion advice and contributions to policy advice led by other agencies) to support decision making by Ministers on government policy matters relating to local government.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
5,011 Revenue Crown 6,465 6,007 6,007
Revenue third parties
5,011 Total Revenue 6,465 6,007 6,007
5,284 Expenses 6,465 6,007 5,395
(273) Net Surplus/(Deficit) 612

The decrease in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates of $458,000 was due to a realignment of funding based on the provision of services across the Vote Internal Affairs portfolios (decrease of $758,000). The decrease was partially offset by an expense transfer from 2012/13 to 2013/14 for the Better Local Government Reform Programme (increase of $300,000).

Actual expenditure was 10% lower than the Supplementary Estimates, primarily due to lower than anticipated personnel costs associated with delays in filling vacancies.

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Policy advice and policy briefings delivered to agreed quality criteria and standards – demonstrated through independent assessment Agreed quality criteria and standards met Achieved Achieved
Minister’s satisfaction with the quality of policy advice (quarterly) Assessed as ‘Satisfied’ or better

Q1: Very Good

Q2: N/A

Q3: Very Good

Q4: Very Good

Q1–2: 9*

Q3–4: No response**

Total cost of an hour of professional staff time devoted to policy unit outputs. $90–$120 New measure $99.02
Total cost of an hour of professional staff time devoted to policy unit outputs (updated***). N/A $137.78

* In 2013/14 we changed the way we collect information for this measure. In accordance with the Treasury Common Policy Indicators Report Data Collection Guidelines, we now undertake surveys on a 6 monthly basis, using a standardised Ministerial Satisfaction Survey format. The different satisfaction results align as follows: Very Poor (1–2), Poor (3–4), Satisfactory (5–6), Good (7–8), Very Good (9–10).

** The Minister for Local Government declined to respond to this survey. Treasury were advised of this result.

*** The TCPOH formula has recently been updated by Treasury to better align it with the amended definition of policy advice costs. Performance measures calculated using both the original and updated formulae have been provided to help readers understand how this change has affected the assessment of performance. Both formulae are shown below.

TCPOH formula
Total cost per
output hour
Original formula Updated formula
Total Policy Advice Costs Total Policy Advice Costs
Total Policy Output and
Non-Policy Output Hours
Total Policy Output Hours
(excluding non-policy advice hours)

Output Expense: Policy Advice – Racing

Under this output expense we provide advice (including second opinion advice and contributions to policy advice led by other agencies) to support decision making by Ministers on government policy matters relating to racing.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
198 Revenue Crown 200 196 196
Revenue third parties
198 Total Revenue 200 196 196
175 Expenses 200 196 169
23 Net Surplus/(Deficit) 27

The decrease in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates of $4,000 was due to a realignment of funding based on the provision of services across the Vote Internal Affairs portfolios.

Actual expenditure was 14% lower than the Supplementary Estimates, primarily due to lower than anticipated turnover of staff and consequently lower recruitment costs.

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Policy advice and policy briefings delivered to agreed quality criteria and standards – demonstrated through independent assessment Agreed quality criteria and standards met Achieved Achieved
Minister’s satisfaction with the quality of policy advice (quarterly) Assessed as ‘Satisfied’ or better

Q1: Good to Very Good

Q2: Good to Very Good

Q3: Good

Q4: Good

Q1–2: 7*

Q3–4: 7

Total cost of an hour of professional staff time devoted to policy unit outputs. $90–$120 New measure $99.02
Total cost of an hour of professional staff time devoted to policy unit outputs (updated**). N/A $137.78

* In 2013/14 we changed the way we collect information for this measure. In accordance with the Treasury Common Policy Indicators Report Data Collection Guidelines, we now undertake surveys on a 6 monthly basis, using a standardised Ministerial Satisfaction Survey format. The different satisfaction results align as follows: Very Poor (1–2), Poor (3–4), Satisfactory (5–6), Good (7–8), Very Good (9–10).

** The TCPOH formula has recently been updated by Treasury to better align it with the amended definition of policy advice costs. Performance measures calculated using both the original and updated formulae have been provided to help readers understand how this change has affected the assessment of performance. Both formulae are shown below.

TCPOH formula
Total cost per
output hour
Original formula Updated formula
Total Policy Advice Costs Total Policy Advice Costs
Total Policy Output and
Non-Policy Output Hours
Total Policy Output Hours
(excluding non-policy advice hours)

Multi-Class Output Appropriation: Regulatory Services [MCOA]

Output Expense: Charities Administration

Under this output expense we deliver services to register charities and that contribute to promoting public trust and confidence in the charitable sector.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
5,164 Revenue Crown 4,569 5,496 5,496
769 Revenue third parties 852 852 802
5,933 Total Revenue 5,421 6,348 6,298
5,902 Expenses 5,421 6,348 6,342
31 Net Surplus/(Deficit) (44)

The increase in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates of $927,000 was due to a realignment of funding based on the provision of services across the Vote Internal Affairs portfolios (increase of $683,000), a retention of underspend from 2012/13 to 2013/14 as a result of efficiency gains in the delivery of outputs (increase of $175,000) and an expense transfer from 2012/13 to 2013/14 for an ongoing programme of initiatives to enable the transformation of systems and processes within the Department of Internal Affairs (increase of $69,000).

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Fully completed applications for registration decided within 40 days of receipt At least 70% Changed measure 70.66%
Fully completed annual returns published within 10 days of receipt At least 95% (of 15,000–30,000) 99.06% 99.28% (of 23,502)
Number of capability-building initiatives developed for the charitable sector Minimum of 3 New measure 3
Stakeholders who accessed or used a capability-building initiative and provided positive feedback At least 75% New measure 100%
Investigations undertaken where no adverse comment was received from the Charities Registration Board or Judiciary on the quality of file preparation and investigative practice At least 99% New measure 100%
Number of registered charities that are reviewed and investigated to ensure that they continue to meet the requirements for registration as a charitable entity 200 investigations 311 218

Output Expense: Regulatory Services

Under this output expense we provide operational policy advice and services to administer all aspects of the regulatory regime under the Public Records Act 2005, including where the Chief Archivist has statutory independence; services to regulate gambling activity, objectionable material and unsolicited electronic messages, and anti-money laundering and countering financing of terrorism; and the Private Security Personnel and Private Investigators Regulations 2011.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
11,119 Revenue Crown 12,205 12,068 12,068
21,641 Revenue third parties 21,470 21,470 19,211
32,760 Total Revenue 33,675 33,538 31,279
30,732 Expenses 32,484 34,096 33,674
2,028 Net Surplus/(Deficit) 1,191 (558) (2,395)

The increase in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates of $1.612 million was due to expenditure associated with gaming activities (increase of $1.749 million) and expense transfers from 2012/13 to 2013/14 for Anti-Money Laundering (increase of $500,000) and for an ongoing programme of initiatives to enable the transformation of systems and processes within the Department of Internal Affairs (increase of $3,000). These increases were partially offset by a realignment of funding based on the provision of services across the Vote Internal Affairs portfolios (decrease of $640,000).

Gambling

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Venue inspections conducted Up to 200 225 343
Provisional audit report to non-club gaming machine societies completed within 6 months 4–10 Changed measure 7
Gambling sector organisation and operator satisfaction with information services – assessed as ‘3’ or better At least 85% 99% 94.24%
Activity Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Applications for gambling licences processed: club and non-club licence renewals 300–350 318 312
Applications for gambling licences processed: other Class 3 and 4 licence applications and Certificates of Approval 4,200–4,600 4,148 4,202

Censorship

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Number of offender-based reports received and reviewed (from national and international enforcement agencies) 50–300 453 440
Number of reports regarding identification of unidentified victims forwarded to enforcement agencies, and actioned within New Zealand 5–50 61 157
Number of images uploaded, as a result of investigation, to the Interpol Child Sexual Exploitation Database 500–800 New measure 4,664*
Number of child exploitation websites being filtered by the specialist software developed and maintained by DIA 300–800 578 585
Activity Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Number of justified appeals compared to the total number of appeals received from websites being filtered is no less than 10% 10% New measure Achieved (0%)

* This area is a high priority for the Censorship group and streamlining of the investigations process has contributed to this high number.

Unsolicited Electronic Messages

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Number of complaints received and analysed within 3 months At least 70% (of 3,600–4,800) New measure 94% (of 8,061)
Civil liability proceedings undertaken – covering warning letters, infringement notices and statements of claim 30–90 31 41

Public Sector Recordkeeping

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Public offices independently audited against recordkeeping standards (Public Records Act 2005) 40 (of 200) 47 40
Appraisal reports submitted to and received by the Chief Archivist processed within 10 weeks At least 80% (of 50–70) 100% 100%
Recordkeeping advice requests responded to within 5 working days of receipt At least 80% (of 300) 89.35% (of 235) Not measured*
Attendee satisfaction with government recordkeeping training courses – assessed as ‘Good’ or ‘Very Good’46 At least 80% (of 200–250) 92.30% (of 177) 96.42% (of 117)

* Due to an administrative error, data for this measure was not recorded in 2013/14. This measure is no longer meaningful as the number of advice queries has dropped considerably as the bulk of guidance is provided through online standards, guidelines and factsheets. The mechanism for measuring the timeliness of replies no longer exists.

Anti-Money Laundering and Countering Financing of Terrorism

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Number of programme reviews undertaken 100–150 New measure 64*
Number of onsite visits conducted 10–15 New measure 10
Remediation plan put in place after programme reviews: within six months At least 70% (of 100–150) New measure 100% (of 33)**
Number of education/information/follow up contacts 1,000–1,500 New measure 570*

* This is a new regulatory regime and the standard set for the year was based on a hypothetical estimate rather than historical activity. The standard has been revised for 2014/15.

** This is a new regulatory regime and the contextual volume for the year was based on a hypothetical estimate rather than historical activity.

Private Security Personnel and Private Investigators

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Ministry of Justice satisfaction with services provided47 Assessed as ‘3’ or better New measure 1–Very Satisfied
Number of complaints investigated, and investigation and validation requests received from the Licensing Authority 50–100 New measure 50

Multi-Class Output Appropriation: Services Supporting the Executive [MCOA]

Output Expense: Coordination of Official Visits and Events

Under this output expense we manage programmes for visiting guests of government, State and ministerial functions, coordinating a range of services in support of ceremonial and commemorative events, and facilitating passage of New Zealand and foreign dignitaries and others authorised by the Crown into and out of New Zealand.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
5,263 Revenue Crown 4,348 5,588 5,588
Revenue third parties 5 5
5,263 Total Revenue 4,353 5,593 5,588
4,600 Expenses 4,353 5,593 5,062
663 Net Surplus/(Deficit) 526

The increase in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates of $1.240 million was due to funding for the visit by the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge in April 2014 (increase of $1.200 million) and a realignment of funding based on the provision of services across the Vote Internal Affairs portfolios (increase of $40,000).

Actual expenditure was 9% lower than the Supplementary Estimates, primarily due to lower than anticipated costs associated with the Royal Tour and a lower level of official visits.

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14

Percentage of visits where the Sponsoring Minister rates as satisfactory the arrangements for:

Design and implementation of programmes for guests of government

90% 100% 100%
Design and implementation of State and ministerial functions 90% 100% Not measured*
Coordination and management of official events 90% 100% 100%
Activity Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Official visits – Heads of State and full guests of government 35-50 visits (average 1–2 days) 49 39
State and Ministerial functions 4–8 3 Not measured*
Commemorative and special events 10–15 15 13
Facilitations of parties through international airports (with an average 1–4 people in each party) 500–600 facilitations 715 782

* No events falling into either of these categories occurred in 2013/14.

Output Expense: Support Services to Members of the Executive

Under this output expense we provide support services for Members of the Executive, including in their capacity as a Member of Parliament, primarily through office personnel and administrative services, information and communication technology, and the provision and management of residential accommodation.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
24,905 Revenue Crown 25,796 25,833 25,832
2 Revenue third parties 35 35 1
24,907 Total Revenue 25,831 25,868 25,833
24,565 Expenses 25,831 25,868 25,975
342 Net Surplus/(Deficit) (142)

The increase in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates of $37,000 was due to a retention of underspend from 2012/13 to 2013/14 as a result of efficiency gains in the delivery of outputs (increase of $164,000), a realignment of funding based on the provision of services across the Vote Internal Affairs portfolios (increase of $143,000) and an expense transfer from 2012/13 to 2013/14 for an ongoing programme of initiatives to enable the transformation of systems and processes within the Department of Internal Affairs (increase of $47,000). These increases were partially offset by a transfer of funding to the Support for Statutory and Other Bodies MCOA and the non-departmental other expense Public Inquiries to provide funding for the Government Inquiry into the Whey Protein Concentrate Contamination Incident (decrease of $300,000) and a reduction in capital charge as a result of asset revaluations in June 2013 (decrease of $17,000).

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Availability of information and communications technology systems, 24 hours a day, 7 days a week No less than 99.5% 99.73% 99.88%
Minister Responsible for Ministerial Services’ satisfaction with the quality and level of support services provided to the Members of the Executive48 Assessed as ‘Satisfied’ or better Very Good Good to Very Good
Activity Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Average number of ministerial office personnel provided 150–170 152 151
Executive Council and Members of the Executive – Salaries and Allowances (PLA) ($8.940m) 26–30 people 28 28
Former Governors-General – Annuities and Other Payments (PLA) ($456,000) 4–8 people 6 6
Former Prime Ministers – Annuities (PLA) ($0.168m) 3–7 people 5 5
Former Prime Ministers – Domestic Travel ($0.270m) Multiple journeys for 12–15 people 12 Multiple journeys for 11 people*
Members of the Executive – Travel ($11.790m) Multiple journeys for 200–240 people 272 267

* Two former PMs/spouses who are eligible for this entitlement have not used it in 2013/14.

Output Expense: VIP Transport Services

Under this output expense we provide chauffeur-driven and self-drive vehicle services for parties specified in legislation, as authorised by Members of the Executive, or who otherwise meet qualifying criteria.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
Revenue Crown
7,053 Revenue third parties 7,415 7,415 7,054
7,053 Total Revenue 7,415 7,415 7,054
7,684 Expenses 7,415 7,415 7,480
(631) Net Surplus/(Deficit) (426)
Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Chauffeur-driven services provided leading to no sustained complaints At least 99.5% (of 17,000–20,000) 99.85 (15 sustained complaints out of 12,083 jobs) 99.94% (11 sustained complaints of 20,397 jobs)
Activity Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Total vehicle fleet 72–77 71 71

Multi-Class Output Appropriation: Support for Statutory and Other Bodies [MCOA]

Output Expense: Commissions of Inquiry and Similar Bodies

Under this output expense we support commissions of inquiry and similar bodies.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
5,520 Revenue Crown 1,366 2,359 2,359
Revenue third parties
5,520 Total Revenue 1,366 2,359 2,359
5,086 Expenses 1,366 2,359 2,031
434 Net Surplus/(Deficit) 328

The increase in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates of $993,000 was due to funding for the Government Inquiry into the Whey Protein Concentrate Contamination Incident (increase of $879,000), an expense transfer from 2012/13 to 2013/14 for the costs associated with administration of the Christchurch Earthquake Appeal Trust (increase of $400,000) and a realignment of funding based on the provision of services across the Vote Internal Affairs portfolios (increase of $114,000). These increases were partially offset by a realignment of expenditure to the Support for Grant Funding Bodies – Internal Affairs output expense for costs associated with administration of the Christchurch Earthquake Appeal Trust (decrease of $400,000).

Actual expenditure was 14% lower than the Supplementary Estimates, primarily due to the timing of costs associated with the Government Inquiry into the Whey Protein Concentrate Contamination Incident and the Confidential Listening and Assistance Service. In-principle expense transfers from 2013/14 to 2014/15 up to a maximum of $0.300 million were approved due to the anticipated timing of expenditure.

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Commissions’ satisfaction with the timeliness and quality of services received Assessed as ‘Good’ or better Good Good
Activity Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Support services provided to the following commissions of inquiry and similar bodies: Confidential Listening and Assistance Service

Output Expense: Statutory and Advisory Body Support – National Archives

Under this output expense we provide advisory and support services to statutory and advisory bodies established under the Public Records Act 2005 in respect of their statutory functions.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
101 Revenue Crown 101 116 116
Revenue third parties
101 Total Revenue 101 116 116
70 Expenses 101 116 100
31 Net Surplus/(Deficit) 16

The increase in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates of $15,000 was due to a realignment of funding based on the provision of services across the Vote Internal Affairs portfolios.

Actual expenditure was 14% lower than the Supplementary Estimates, primarily due to lower provision of services to third parties and accordingly, lower expenditure associated with the provision of services.

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Statutory body member satisfaction with the quality of support received49 Assessed as ‘Satisfied’ or better Satisfied Very Good
Support services provided to the following statutory bodies advising the Minister – meetings supported:

Archives Council

4 4 4

Output Expense: Statutory and Advisory Body Support – National Library

Under this output expense we provide services and advice to statutory and advisory bodies established under the National Library of New Zealand (Te Puna Mātauranga o Aotearoa) Act 2003 and the Public Lending Right for New Zealand Authors Act 2008 in respect of their statutory functions.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
93 Revenue Crown 98 98 98
Revenue third parties 7 7
93 Total Revenue 105 105 98
3 Expenses 105 105 62
90 Net Surplus/(Deficit) 36

Actual expenditure was 41% lower than the Supplementary Estimates, primarily due to lower than anticipated travel costs.

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Statutory body member satisfaction with the quality of support received Assessed as ‘Satisfied’ or better Good Very Good
Activity Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Support services provided to the following statutory bodies – meetings supported:

Guardians Kaitiaki of the Alexander Turnbull Library

4 5 3*

Library and Information Advisory Committee

4 5 4

Public Lending Right Advisory Group

1 1 2

* This is a demand-driven measure. The statutory requirement is for the Guardians Kaitiaki of the Alexander Turnbull Library to meet 3 times a year.

Output Expense: Statutory Body Support – Gambling Commission

Under this output expense we provide services and advice to the Gambling Commission to enable the Commission to discharge its responsibilities.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
Revenue Crown
894 Revenue third parties 1,158 1,158 835
894 Total Revenue 1,158 1,158 835
894 Expenses 1,158 1,158 835
Net Surplus/(Deficit)

Actual expenditure was 28% lower than the Supplementary Estimates, primarily due to a lower than anticipated number of appeals to the Gambling Commission resulting in lower legal costs.

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Gambling Commission’s satisfaction with the support services provided50 Assessed as ‘4’ or better 4.6 4.5

Output Expense: Statutory Body Support – Local Government Commission

Under this output expense we provide advisory and support services to the Local Government Commission in respect of its statutory functions.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
1,604 Revenue Crown 1,046 1,872 1,872
Revenue third parties
1,604 Total Revenue 1,046 1,872 1,872
1,190 Expenses 1,046 1,872 2,047
414 Net Surplus/(Deficit) (175)

The increase in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates of $826,000 was due to expense transfers from 2012/13 to 2013/14 for Local Government Reorganisation (increase of $400,000), an ongoing programme of initiatives to enable the transformation of systems and processes within the Department of Internal Affairs (increase of $102,000) and a realignment of funding based on the provision of services across the Vote Internal Affairs portfolios (increase of $324,000).

Actual expenditure was 9% higher than the Supplementary Estimates, primarily due to additional complexities and accordingly, scoping of work associated with the amalgamation of local councils.

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Local Government Commission’s satisfaction with the quality of advice and support services received51 Assessed as ‘3’ or above 4 3

Output Expense: Support for Grant Funding Bodies – Community and Voluntary Sector

Under this output expense we provide operational and secretariat support for grant funding bodies, and includes supporting member appointment processes. The focus of operational support is on processing grant applications and grant decisions on behalf of the grant funding bodies.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
324 Revenue Crown 309 307 307
Revenue third parties
324 Total Revenue 309 307 307
322 Expenses 309 307 323
2 Net Surplus/(Deficit) (16)

The decrease in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates of $2,000 was due to a realignment of funding based on the provision of services across the Vote Internal Affairs portfolios (decrease of $26,000). The decrease is partially offset by an expense transfer from 2012/13 to 2013/14 for an ongoing programme of initiatives to enable the transformation of systems and processes within the Department of Internal Affairs (increase of $24,000). Actual expenditure was 5% higher than the Supplementary Estimates, primarily due to higher business support costs.

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Grant applications processed from receipt to payment within agreed timeframes At least 95% 100% (of 176) 93%*
Activity Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14

Support services provided to the following grant funding bodies – committee meetings organised:

Norman Kirk Memorial Trust

Pacific Development and Conservation Trust

Peace and Disarmament Education Trust

Vietnam Veterans and Their Families Trust

Combined: 10 11 10

* The Pacific Development and Conservation Trust, which has a two-tiered application process, is excluded from this analysis. There were difficulties in capturing the results accurately in our current system and it is likely the result is better than reported. These issues will be resolved with the introduction of a new Grants and Client Management System in October 2014 and with the valuable information gained this year we are confident the target will be met in 2014/15.

Output Expense: Support for Grant Funding Bodies – Internal Affairs

Under this output expense we provide operational and secretariat support for grant funding bodies, including supporting member appointment processes. The focus of operational support is on processing grant applications and grant decisions on behalf of the grant funding bodies.

Revenue and output expenses ($000)
2012/13 2013/14
Actual Mains Supps. Actual
1,194 Revenue Crown 66 911 911
8,241 Revenue third parties 9,617 9,232 8,885
9,435 Total Revenue 9,683 10,143 9,796
9,265 Expenses 9,683 10,143 9,572
170 Net Surplus/(Deficit) 224

The increase in the budget between the Main Estimates and the Supplementary Estimates of $460,000 was due to a realignment of expenditure from the Commissions of Inquiry and Similar Bodies output expense for costs associated with administration of the Christchurch Earthquake Appeal Trust (increase of $400,000), a realignment of funding based on the provision of services across the Vote Internal Affairs portfolios (increase of $369,000), a transfer of funding from the Community Information and Advisory Services MCOA to reflect a realignment of expenditure for the provision of secretariat support for the Chinese Poll Tax Heritage Trust (increase of $74,000) and an expense transfer from 2012/13 to 2013/14 for an ongoing programme of initiatives to enable the transformation of systems and processes within the Department of Internal Affairs (increase of $2,000). These increases were partially offset by a lower provision of services to the Lottery Grants Board (decrease of $385,000).

Actual expenditure was 6% lower than the Supplementary Estimates, primarily due to lower provision of services to the Lottery Grants Board.

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Distribution committee member satisfaction with operational report received52 95% of sample reviewed 95% 100%
Funding grants processed from receipt to payment within agreed timeframes At least 95% Changed measure 90%*
Grant distribution committee decisions are consistent with priorities, policies and procedures At least 95% of sample reviewed New measure

99.6%: Lottery

100%: Trust

Activity Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14

Support services provided to the following grant funding bodies – committee meetings organised:

Distribution Committees of the New Zealand Lottery Grants Board

New Zealand Winston Churchill Memorial Trust

Chinese Poll Tax Heritage Trust

5,700–6,200

(Changed measure)

62 5,330**

* There are a number of problems related to extracting accurate dates from the systems used to process grant applications, resulting in an unknown margin of error. The implementation of the Grants and Client Management System during 2014/15 will resolve this problem.

** This is a demand-driven measure, and the actual number of applications received did not reach expected levels of demand.

Multi-Category Appropriation: Community Funding Schemes (MCA)

The single overarching purpose of this appropriation is to support communities and voluntary sector organisations.

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Case studies completed that demonstrate benefits to community grant funding recipients Achieved N/A Achieved
Category: Community Development Scheme

This category is limited to providing grants of up to three years to community organisations for projects to achieve improved economic, social and cultural well being.

Performance measure: Exempted from performance measurement.

Category: Community Internship Programme

This category is limited to providing grants for community groups with identified needs to employ experienced people from the public, private and community sectors in short-term internships.

Performance measure: Exempted from performance measurement.

Category: Community Organisation Grants Scheme

This category is limited to providing locally distributed grants to community organisations for programmes that provide social services.

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
Two case studies completed to assess grants’ communities benefit from social services provided by grass-roots non-profit organisations with these grants Achieved N/A Achieved53
Category: Digital Literacy and Connection

This category is limited to providing funding to selected providers for improving communities’ access to and capability to use digital tools.

Performance measure: Exempted from performance measurement.

Category: Disarmament Education Grants

This category is limited to providing grants to fund activities to support New Zealand non-government organisations in the disarmament education field.

Performance measure: Exempted from performance measurement.

Category: Support for Volunteering

This category is limited to providing funding to Volunteering New Zealand, regional volunteer centres and various targeted projects within the community.

Performance measure: Exempted from performance measurement.

Youth Workers Training Scheme

This category is limited to providing grants for information and training for both paid and voluntary youth workers.

Performance measure: Exempted from performance measurement.

Appropriation: Pitt Island Wharf Reconstruction

Under this appropriation we provide an operating grant to the Chatham Islands Enterprise Trust for the reconstruction of Pitt Island Wharf.

Performance Information
Standard 2012/13 2013/14
A deed in relation to the Pitt Island Wharf reconstruction is agreed and signed between the Chatham Islands Enterprise Trust and the Department Achieved N/A Achieved

Back to top

Footnotes

[35] Last year – grant distribution committee procedures and decisions reviewed (sample-based) – consistent with requirements and guiding principles.

[36] This figure was reported as 5,514 in the Annual Report 2012/13, which is the total number of COGS applications received, including applications not considered by COGS committees because they are ineligible or incomplete. We have now changed the way we define the measure, and are reporting the total number of applications considered by COGS committees we have updated the 2013/14 figure accordingly.

[37] Last year’s standard was within 4 months.

[38] Identity Services customers are asked to assess the quality of the service they received on a five-point scale: Very Good, Good, Satisfied, Poor, Very Poor.

[39] MCDEM transferred to DPMC on 1 April 2014. Performance indicators are reported for the period up to 30 March 2014 and unless otherwise stated are an average of Q1, Q2, and Q3 data.

[40] Customers are asked to assess quality of translation services provided on a five point scale: Very Good, Good, Satisfied, Poor, Very Poor.

[41] MCDEM transferred to DPMC on 1 April 2014. Performance indicators are reported for the period up to 31 March 2014 and unless otherwise stated are an average of Q1, Q2 and Q3 data.

[42] MCDEM transferred to DPMC on 1 April 2014. Performance indicators are reported for the period up to 31 March 2014 and unless otherwise stated are an average of Q1, Q2 and Q3 data.

[43] CDEM Group stakeholders and course attendees are asked to assess the quality of services and information received on a five point scale: Very Good, Good, Satisfied, Poor, Very Poor.

[44] Training course attendees are asked to assess the training received on a five-point scale: Very Good, Good, Satisfied, Poor, Very Poor.

[45] MCDEM transferred to DPMC on 1 April 2014. Performance indicators are reported for the period up to 31 March 2014 and unless otherwise stated are an average of Q1, Q2 and Q3 data.

[46] Training course attendees are asked to assess the usefulness of the training received on a five point scale: Very Good, Good, Satisfied, Poor, Very Poor.

[47] The Ministry of Justice are asked to assess the service provided on a five point scale: 1–Very Satisifed, 2–Satisifed, 3–Neutral, 4–Unsatisifed, 5–Very Unsatisifed.

[48] The Minister is asked to assess support services provided on a five-point scale: Very Good, Good, Satisfied, Poor, Very Poor.

[49] Statutory body members are asked to assess the quality support received on a five-point scale: Very Good, Good, Satisfied, Poor, Very Poor.

[50] Commission members are asked to assess support received on a five point numerical scale.

[51] The Local Government Commission is asked to assess the support it receives on a five point numerical scale.

[52] This measure should refer to satisfaction with operational support, not report.

[53] Two case studies have been completed and will be included in the November 2014 Community Matters online publication.

Back to top